Insight

Combating Punitive Damages Awards on Appeal

While the trial team’s deep knowledge of the trial record is an important resource, if that team does not also have appellate experience, consider an appellate specialist to lead the next phase of the case.

Punitive Damages
LS

Lynn Kappelman and Dawn Solowey

September 14, 2017 10:10 AM

No company wants to confront a large punitive damages verdict in an employment case. All at once, the employer faces demoralized witnesses, climbing legal fees, urgent decisions, and negative publicity. Rather than panic, pick a top-notch appellate team and move quickly on a strategic action plan for post-trial motions and appeal.

Procedural Considerations

Following an adverse verdict, time is of the essence. As soon as judgment enters, the clock starts ticking on quick and important deadlines for motions for new trial, remittitur, and judgment as a matter of law. Drafting these motions is a substantial undertaking that requires detailed study of the trial record, so it is critical to get the appellate team going. It is not obvious that the trial team should handle post-trial motions and appeal.

While the trial team’s deep knowledge of the trial record is an important resource, if that team does not also have appellate experience, consider an appellate specialist to lead the next phase of the case.

Post-trial motions are an opportunity to ask the trial judge to take a hard look at the verdict. The judge will typically have broad discretion to decide whether the punitive award was excessive, whether the evidence supports the verdict, and whether errors contributed to the award. It is critical to raise all appellate issues in the post-trial motions to avoid waiver. Later at the appellate stage, the team will need to make tough decisions to focus on those arguments that have the greatest chances of success in actually achieving removal or reduction of the punitive award.

Substantive Arguments for Reduction of a Punitive Award

  1. Evidence Does Not Support Liability for Punitive Damages

    The company should first consider whether there is an argument that the evidence does not support a punitive award. The evidentiary standard for punitive damages is high, and there are often persuasive arguments that the question should never have gone to the jury in the first place and that the verdict on punitive liability should be reversed entirely.

  2. Punitive Damages Are Unconstitutionally Excessive

    The Supreme Court has enacted three guideposts for identifying an unconstitutionally excessive punishment: the degree of reprehensibility of the defendant’s conduct; the ratio of the punitive damages to the actual or potential harm to the plaintiff; and the disparity between the punitive award and the civil penalties applicable to comparable conduct. See State Farm Mutual Auto Ins. Co. v. Campbell, 538 U.S. 408 (2003) and BMW of North America, Inc. v. Gore, 517 U.S. 559 (1996).

    On the reprehensibility factor, the company will want to mine the trial record for evidence that shows, for example, that the conduct was not severe, was not physically harmful, was brief, or that demonstrates that the company took mitigating remedial measures.

    For the ratio factor, the team should dive into the jurisdiction’s case law for parameters around the acceptable ratio between punitive and compensatory damages. Generally, if compensatory damages are also substantial, the acceptable ratio is lower. The company should point to cases with similar claims or facts that have substantially reduced the punitive award. See, e.g., Zakre v. Norddeutsche Landesbank Girozentrale, 344 F. App’x 628, 631 (2nd Cir. 2009) (in retaliatory-termination case, approving reduction of punitive damages from $2.5 million to $600,000); Mendez-Matos v. Municipality of Guaynabo, 557 F.3d 36, 56 (1st Cir. 2009) (reducing $350,000 punitive award to $35,000); and CGB Occupational Therapy v. RHA/Pennsylvania, Inc. Nursing Homes, 499 F.3d 184 (3d Cir. 2007) (punitive award reduced from original $30 million to $750,000).

    The factor regarding fines for comparable conduct looks at the disparity between the punitive award and civil penalties authorized in comparable cases. Such civil penalties might include state employment laws or federal damages caps, for example.

  3. Punitive Damages Are Excessive Under Federal Law

    An employer can also argue that a punitive damages award is excessive under federal common law. The key is to compare the verdict with other punitive awards in the jurisdiction, especially in cases with similar facts and claims, to show the court that the verdict in question is outside the norms for the jurisdiction.

  4. Additional Arguments against Punitive Damages

    An employer can also consider additional arguments. For example, the award may be excessive given defendants’ financial condition. The award may be the result of juror passion and prejudice, perhaps triggered by objectionable evidence, an improper closing statement, or a counsel’s suggestion (frowned on in many jurisdictions) of a specific dollar amount for the verdict.

----------------------------------

Lynn Kappelman is a partner in Seyfarth Shaw's Boston office and co-chairs the firm’s National Trial Team. Dawn Solowey is senior counsel in Seyfarth’s Boston office and a member of the firm’s National Trial Team and Appellate Team. Both Ms. Kappelman and Ms. Solowey have substantial experience in representing employers in high-stakes post-trial motions and appeals around the country.

Related Articles

IN PARTNERSHIP

Trial Lawyers Protect Employees, Make Workplaces Safer


by Esquire Bank

Trial lawyers Jeffrey Laffey and Sean Flaherty fight hard for injured workers because of their own personal experiences with the aftermath of workplace injuries.

Lawyers Jeffrey Laffey and Sean Flaherty Protect Employees

IN PARTNERSHIP

How A Trial Lawyer Overcame Adversity and is Paying It Forward


by Esquire Bank

After fighting to take the bar exam, Matt Nakajima continues to beat the odds for his clients as a personal injury trial lawyer, winning millions in settlements.

Trial Lawyer Matt Nakajima Overcame Adversity and Gives Back

IN PARTNERSHIP

Civil Litigation: How Trial Lawyers’ Efforts Help Communities


by Esquire Bank

There are many upfront costs when trying cases on a contingency fee model. However, Reza Torkzadeh is willing to fight to get the justice his clients deserve.

How Lawyers Like Reza Torkzadeh Help Communities

IN PARTNERSHIP

When the Result Means Everything


by Lyons & Simmons

Michael Lyons and Christopher Simmons, Texas-based trial attorneys and founders of the firm Lyons & Simmons, are dedicated to finding justice for their clients.

Two suited lawyers walk side by side while talking

IN PARTNERSHIP

Leadership and Commitment


by Justin Smulison

Malone Law leader and 2016 Medical Malpractice Law – Plaintiffs “Lawyer of the Year” Adam Malone discusses how his success transcends the courtroom and helps strengthen public and legal communities.

Suited man standing with arm resting on table

IN PARTNERSHIP

Protecting the Public


by Justin Smulison

Burg Simpson founder and three-time Best Lawyers® “Lawyer of the Year” honoree Michael S. Burg discusses the impact of the firm’s national cases and how its trial lawyers continue to add to the firm’s 45-year legacy.

Lawyers pose for headshot with black background

Punishment and Deterrents


by David A. Yeagley

Facing a jury instruction on punitive damages? Here’s a cheat sheet to help you secure the best possible outcome for the defendant you represent.

Seated man wearing glasses and looking down

Colorado's Best Lawyers 2022


by Best Lawyers

Our 2022 Colorado's Best Lawyers publication features top-ranked legal talent in Boulder, Denver and Western Colorado.

Colorado's Best Lawyers 2022

Selection Protection


by Bradley M. Cosgrove and Robert A. Clifford

Jury Research in High Profile Cases

Jury Research in High Profile Cases

A Trial Icon


by Sean Stonefield

Dan Cogdell on his almost four decades of courtroom success.

Dan Cogdell Best Lawyers 2020

Safeguarding the Community


by Sean Stonefield

When companies put profits over safety, trial attorney Daniel J. T. Sciano steps in.

Daniel J. T. Sciano of Tinsman & Sciano, Inc

Trending Articles

2025 Best Lawyers Awards Announced: Honoring Outstanding Legal Professionals Across the U.S.


by Jennifer Verta

Introducing the 31st edition of The Best Lawyers in America and the fifth edition of Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in America.

Digital map of the United States illuminated by numerous bright lights

Unveiling the 2025 Best Lawyers Awards Canada: Celebrating Legal Excellence


by Jennifer Verta

Presenting the 19th edition of The Best Lawyers in Canada and the 4th edition of Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in Canada.

Digital map of Canadathis on illuminated by numerous bright lights

Legal Distinction on Display: 15th Edition of The Best Lawyers in France™


by Best Lawyers

The industry’s best lawyers and firms working in France are revealed in the newly released, comprehensive the 15th Edition of The Best Lawyers in France™.

French flag in front of country's outline

Presenting the 2025 Best Lawyers Editions in Chile, Colombia, Peru and Puerto Rico


by Jennifer Verta

Celebrating top legal professionals in South America and the Caribbean.

Flags of Puerto Rico, Chile, Colombia, and Peru, representing countries featured in the Best Lawyers

Unveiling the 2025 Best Lawyers Editions in Brazil, Mexico, Portugal and South Africa


by Jennifer Verta

Best Lawyers celebrates the finest in law, reaffirming its commitment to the global legal community.

Flags of Brazil, Mexico, Portugal and South Africa, representing Best Lawyers countries

Announcing the 13th Edition of Best Lawyers Rankings in the United Kingdom


by Best Lawyers

Best Lawyers is proud to announce the newest edition of legal rankings in the United Kingdom, marking the 13th consecutive edition of awards in the country.

British flag in front of country's outline

Prop 36 California 2024: California’s Path to Stricter Sentencing and Criminal Justice Reform


by Jennifer Verta

Explore how Prop 36 could shape California's sentencing laws and justice reform.

Illustrated Hands Breaking Chains Against a Bright Red Background

Announcing the 16th Edition of the Best Lawyers in Germany Rankings


by Best Lawyers

Best Lawyers announces the 16th edition of The Best Lawyers in Germany™, featuring a unique set of rankings that highlights Germany's top legal talent.

German flag in front of country's outline

Celebrating Excellence in Law: 11th Edition of Best Lawyers in Italy™


by Best Lawyers

Best Lawyers announces the 11th edition of The Best Lawyers in Italy™, which features an elite list of awards showcasing Italy's current legal talent.

Italian flag in front of country's outline

Tampa Appeals Court ‘Sends Clear Message,” Ensuring School Tax Referendum Stays on Ballot


by Gregory Sirico

Hillsborough County's tax referendum is back on the 2024 ballot, promising $177 million for schools and empowering residents to decide the future of education.

Graduation cap in air surrounded by pencils and money

Find the Best Lawyers for Your Needs


by Jennifer Verta

Discover how Best Lawyers simplifies the attorney search process.

A focused woman with dark hair wearing a green top and beige blazer, working on a tablet in a dimly

Key Developments and Trends in U.S. Commercial Litigation


by Justin Smulison

Whether it's multibillion-dollar water cleanliness verdicts or college athletes vying for the right to compensation, the state of litigation remains strong.

Basketball sits in front of stacks of money

Woman on a Mission


by Rebecca Blackwell

Baker Botts partner and intellectual property chair Christa Brown-Sanford discusses how she juggles work, personal life, being a mentor and leadership duties.

Woman in green dress crossing her arms and posing for headshot

Best Lawyers Celebrates Women in the Law: Ninth Edition


by Alliccia Odeyemi

Released in both print and digital form, Best Lawyers Ninth Edition of Women in the Law features stories of inspiring leadership and timely legal issues.

Lawyer in green dress stands with hands on table and cityscape in background

The Human Cost


by Justin Smulison

2 new EU laws aim to reshape global business by enforcing ethical supply chains, focusing on human rights and sustainability

Worker wearing hat stands in field carrying equipemtn

Beyond the Billables


by Michele M. Jochner

In a recently conducted, comprehensive study, data reveals a plethora of hidden realities that parents working full-time in the legal industry face every day.

Women in business attire pushing stroller takes a phone call