Insight

Staged Accident Evidence Gets $3,375,000 Trial Verdict Reversed

An update on indictments in the Louisiana commercial vehicle staged accident ring.

J. Edward McAuliffe III

J. Edward McAuliffe III

September 30, 2024 04:57 PM

We previously reported that two individuals had been indicted for the murder of Cornelius Garrison who was killed only days after being indicted as a ring leader in commercial vehicle staged accident conspiracies in Louisiana. Now, only a day after that murder indictment was made public, evidence that some Plaintiffs had been in contact with Garrison contemporaneously with their accident has garnered the reversal of a multi-million-dollar jury verdict in Orleans Parish. The case is Straughter v. Occidental Fire & Cas. Co. of N.C., 2023-CA-0480 cons. 2023-CA-0481 (La. App. 4 Cir. 05/08/2024).

PRE-TRIAL CIRCUMSTANCES

The case revolved around a July 17, 2018, accident in which a 2008 Ford Mustang with three occupants was allegedly struck by an 18-wheeler. Early in 2023, Defendants did not oppose some motions filed by Plaintiffs, including summary judgment on liability. The matter was set for trial on March 27, 2023. On March 13, 2023, Defendants alleged they discovered evidence that Cornelius Garrison, the supposed staged accident ringleader, had been in contact with Plaintiffs multiple times on the date of the accident.

Defendants filed a Motion for Continuance of trial on March 21, 2023, along with a petition to annul the prior consent judgments. Pleadings alleged Plaintiffs had concealed telephone numbers from the Defense; that certain telephone numbers were discovered in medical records and the police report that were not the telephone numbers provided to the Defense by Plaintiffs; and that the numbers located in medical and police records were those found in the telephone records of Cornelius Garrison.

Plaintiffs countered that the discovery deadline had passed, Defendants knew of the possible fraud before March, and that Defendants had answered in discovery that the accident had similarities to other staged accidents. The trial court denied the motion to continue, relying on the fact that the discovery deadline had passed.

Trial proceeded, and the two Plaintiffs at trial were awarded a total of $3,375,000.

ON APPEAL

The trial was appealed on several grounds, but the majority of the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeal found the need only to address the Motion for Continuance. In short, they found the trial court had abused its discretion in not granting the continuance for the defense.

The opinion by Judge Karen Herman noted that judges are given broad discretion on whether or not to grant a continuance. They must weight several factors, including diligence, good faith, reasonable grounds, the right for an expeditious hearing, fairness, and the need for orderly administration of justice. Judge Herman also pointed out that the appellate courts should only interfere with a trial judge’s determination in these matters “with reluctance and in what are considered extreme cases,” citing to Wilkerson v. Darden Direct Distribution, Inc., 53,263, p. 13 (La. App. 2 Cir. 3/4/20), 293 So. 3d 146, 154.

Weighing all these factors and more, Judge Herman’s opinion stated:

We find that the possibility of fraud being perpetrated on the judicial system warrants this Court’s inference with the trial court’s discretion and constitutes good cause for a continuance under La. C.C.P. art. 1601. The record shows that Garrison was an indicted conspirator in 50 staged motor vehicle accidents with 18-wheelers and the telephone records show that Plaintiffs had placed or received approximately 30 calls to and from Garrison on the day of the accident, both before and after the collision. The evidence thus suggests the real possibility of fraud, similar to the cases investigated by U.S. Attorney’s Office. Nevertheless, the trial court permitted the trial to proceed and the jury ultimately rendered a verdict of over 3 million dollars in damages. We find the trial court abused its discretion in refusing to grant a continuance of the trial to allow Defendants to investigate the matter further.

Judge Brown dissented, largely on procedural grounds. The Defense filed pleadings related to fraud in the trial court, which were denied and has subsequently been appealed. Judge Brown found that the instant matter was moot, as there was a finding below that fraud had not occurred, and that matter would soon be before the Court. Judge Brown stated she otherwise would have stayed this appeal pending the appeal on the fraud ruling below.

Judge Jenkins wrote a separate dissent, focusing on Defendants’ failure to allege fraud as an affirmative defense, although they had alluded to such in prior discovery responses. Defendants also conceded to the early 2023 partial summary judgment on liability. She also noted Defendants had not introduced any evidence at the hearing on their Motion for Continuance. She would have upheld the trial court’s ruling.

THE RESULTS

Under the circumstances of this case, the appellate court decided that a continuance was justified given a fairly clear set of facts suggesting fraud. However, the devil is in the details. Had the evidence of alleged fraud not been so clear, and even perhaps had the jury verdict not been so large, the matter may have gone the other way. It would seem the totality of circumstances and potential large injustice in the eventual trial verdict likely were the most weighty factors swaying the majority.

It is also noteworthy that Judge Karen Herman is former prosecutor and was a long-time jurist on the Orleans Parish Criminal District Court bench before making her way to the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeal. It is unsurprising this opinion was written by her, given her experience.

Trending Articles

2025 Best Lawyers Awards Announced: Honoring Outstanding Legal Professionals Across the U.S.


by Jennifer Verta

Introducing the 31st edition of The Best Lawyers in America and the fifth edition of Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in America.

Digital map of the United States illuminated by numerous bright lights

Unveiling the 2025 Best Lawyers Awards Canada: Celebrating Legal Excellence


by Jennifer Verta

Presenting the 19th edition of The Best Lawyers in Canada and the 4th edition of Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in Canada.

Digital map of Canadathis on illuminated by numerous bright lights

Legal Distinction on Display: 15th Edition of The Best Lawyers in France™


by Best Lawyers

The industry’s best lawyers and firms working in France are revealed in the newly released, comprehensive the 15th Edition of The Best Lawyers in France™.

French flag in front of country's outline

Announcing the 13th Edition of Best Lawyers Rankings in the United Kingdom


by Best Lawyers

Best Lawyers is proud to announce the newest edition of legal rankings in the United Kingdom, marking the 13th consecutive edition of awards in the country.

British flag in front of country's outline

Announcing the 16th Edition of the Best Lawyers in Germany Rankings


by Best Lawyers

Best Lawyers announces the 16th edition of The Best Lawyers in Germany™, featuring a unique set of rankings that highlights Germany's top legal talent.

German flag in front of country's outline

Prop 36 California 2024: California’s Path to Stricter Sentencing and Criminal Justice Reform


by Jennifer Verta

Explore how Prop 36 could shape California's sentencing laws and justice reform.

Illustrated Hands Breaking Chains Against a Bright Red Background

Celebrating Excellence in Law: 11th Edition of Best Lawyers in Italy™


by Best Lawyers

Best Lawyers announces the 11th edition of The Best Lawyers in Italy™, which features an elite list of awards showcasing Italy's current legal talent.

Italian flag in front of country's outline

Combating Nuclear Verdicts: Empirically Supported Strategies to Deflate the Effects of Anchoring Bias


by Sloan L. Abernathy

Sometimes a verdict can be the difference between amicability and nuclear level developments. But what is anchoring bias and how can strategy combat this?

Lawyer speaking in courtroom with crowd and judge in the foreground

Things to Do Before a Car Accident Happens to You


by Ellie Shaffer

In a car accident, certain things are beyond the point of no return, while some are well within an individual's control. Here's how to stay legally prepared.

Car dashcam recording street ahead

Tampa Appeals Court ‘Sends Clear Message,” Ensuring School Tax Referendum Stays on Ballot


by Gregory Sirico

Hillsborough County's tax referendum is back on the 2024 ballot, promising $177 million for schools and empowering residents to decide the future of education.

Graduation cap in air surrounded by pencils and money

The Push and Pitfalls of New York’s Attempt to Expand Wrongful Death Recovery


by Elizabeth M. Midgley and V. Christopher Potenza

The New York State Legislature recently went about updating certain wrongful death provisions and how they can be carried out in the future. Here's the latest.

Red tape blocking off a section of street

Find the Best Lawyers for Your Needs


by Jennifer Verta

Discover how Best Lawyers simplifies the attorney search process.

A focused woman with dark hair wearing a green top and beige blazer, working on a tablet in a dimly

Key Developments and Trends in U.S. Commercial Litigation


by Justin Smulison

Whether it's multibillion-dollar water cleanliness verdicts or college athletes vying for the right to compensation, the state of litigation remains strong.

Basketball sits in front of stacks of money

Is Premises Liability the Same as Negligence?


by Jeremy Wilson and Taylor Rodney Marks

In today's age, we are always on the move, often inhabiting spaces we don't own. But what happens when someone else's property injures you or someone you know?

A pair of silhouetted legs falling down a hole with yellow background

Woman on a Mission


by Rebecca Blackwell

Baker Botts partner and intellectual property chair Christa Brown-Sanford discusses how she juggles work, personal life, being a mentor and leadership duties.

Woman in green dress crossing her arms and posing for headshot

Best Lawyers Celebrates Women in the Law: Ninth Edition


by Alliccia Odeyemi

Released in both print and digital form, Best Lawyers Ninth Edition of Women in the Law features stories of inspiring leadership and timely legal issues.

Lawyer in green dress stands with hands on table and cityscape in background